Overview of the Leasing Crime of the Century

The incredible story of how a former bodybuilder stole almost €112m from a host of top lessors and banks reads like a John Grisham thriller. No wonder six books
have already been written on the scandal that has shaken to the core the likes of Nordea Finans and Siemens Financial Services. Jason T Hesse investigates.

“I am Stein Bagger. I am a fugitive from Europe and I’m here to turn myself in.”

This was how the former chief executive of IT Factory, who was wanted by Interpol for aggravated fraud and forgery, handed himself into the Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) on 6 December 2008, nine days after he went missing from his hotel in Dubai.

He was extradited to Denmark the following week and was immediately arrested.

Over the past decade, 42-year-old Stein Bagger, a former bodybuilder and protein-shake salesman, had rapidly become a Danish technology superstar.

Between 2003 and 2007, Bagger was responsible for growing IT Factory’s revenue 69 times, and its profit by an even more impressive 288 times, to reach DKK121 million (€16.2 million) in 2007.

How well do you really know your competitors?

Access the most comprehensive Company Profiles on the market, powered by GlobalData. Save hours of research. Gain competitive edge.

Company Profile – free sample

Thank you!

Your download email will arrive shortly

Not ready to buy yet? Download a free sample

We are confident about the unique quality of our Company Profiles. However, we want you to make the most beneficial decision for your business, so we offer a free sample that you can download by submitting the below form

By GlobalData
Visit our Privacy Policy for more information about our services, how we may use, process and share your personal data, including information of your rights in respect of your personal data and how you can unsubscribe from future marketing communications. Our services are intended for corporate subscribers and you warrant that the email address submitted is your corporate email address.

Bagger was charged with forging the signature of IT Factory’s chairman, Asger Jensby, as well as fraudulently selling and leasing back non-existent software products to some of Scandinavia’s biggest banks and lessors, including Nordea Finans, SEB, Hewlett-Packard Financial Services, Siemens Financial Services, De Lage Landen and others (see below).

In total, Bagger admitted to defrauding companies of DKK831 million and of funnelling millions to his own companies abroad.

Bagger was also charged with fraudulently changing some of the details on contracts – for example, changing five-year contracts to three-month contracts, then either forging signatures or signing on behalf of his management board to confirm the amendments.

Last month, Bagger finally appeared in court to answer to 61 counts of forgery and falsifying signatures on contracts. Following a short three-day trial, Bagger was sentenced to seven years in prison.

‘Best IT Company’

Before the company was exposed as fraudulent, it had been reporting extremely healthy results, with Ernst & Young naming Bagger ‘Danish Entrepreneur of the Year 2008’, and Danish magazine Computerworld describing the business as the ‘Best IT Company’ for two consecutive years.

According to Asger Jensby, this year IT Factory’s profit was expected to “roughly quadruple”.

But speaking to Leasing Life, Boris Frederiksen, IT Factory’s state-appointed liquidator, said that the company was mostly hot air.

“Most of activities in IT Factory have turned out to be fraudulent,” Frederiksen said. “It simply wasn’t real.”

But IT Factory did have some genuine software on offer, specifically platform-as-a-service software, which Frederiksen managed to sell to an undisclosed German company last March, after the bankruptcy.

Yet lessors should not expect their money back anytime soon, Frederiksen said.

“The winding up of the rest of the bankruptcy estate and its liquidation is ongoing, and will take at least a couple of years, I’m afraid,” he added.

Of the total DKK831 million that Bagger admitted to defrauding, there is still around DKK220 million that needs to be accounted for, Frederiksen continued.

“We still have problems accounting for around DKK220 million. The rest was spent on things that we know about – paying wages, instalments to the leasing companies, rent, developing software, as well as paying for some of Stein Bagger’s personal expenses.”

However, many commentators believe that Bagger may have sent the money offshore, to be accessed once he is free.

“We just don’t know where it is – we are still working on it,” Frederiksen said.

“We might be able to retrace some of it, probably a small amount, but it could be gone entirely.

“Bagger could have already spent it or it might be sitting in an account, or invested in assets, somewhere outside of Denmark.”

To claim some of their capital back, most lessors have pitted their hopes on claims against KPMG, IT Factory’s auditors, rather than against the company’s estate, which
has entered bankruptcy.

‘Issuing a writ’

The claim against KPMG will be led by Frederiksen who, as liquidator of the estate, will represent all of IT Factory’s creditors.

“We will be issuing a writ of summons through the court at the beginning of July,” said Frederiksen. “But the court case itself will most likely take a couple of years.”

The lessors’ main claim against KPMG is that the accountants had not picked up on any irregularities at IT Factory.

“That is where the main fault is, as we see it,” explained Nicolai Thornemann Østergaard, a lawyer at Denmark’s fifth-largest law firm, Lett, which, among other creditors,
represents an international lessor.

“KPMG audited the financial accounts for IT Factory, but did not pick up any of the obligations the company had towards the leasing companies.”

According to Østergaard, the accountancy firm claims that IT Factory’s agreements do not actually constitute leasing and this explains why it had
not made any notes about the problem.

Yet Østergaard said he believes KPMG cannot win the argument.

“The bottom line is that we have tons of evidence that shows that: one, they were aware that IT Factory had leasing obligations; and two, if they didn’t know it, then,
according to all Danish accounting standards, they should have asked follow-up questions, or should at least have noted it down if they were to do the job properly,” Østergaard said.

Frederiksen, too, is confident he has a strong case.

“It is obviously up to the court, but we wouldn’t initiate these legal proceedings unless we had an optimistic view of the outcome,” he commented.

“It is a fact that KPMG was aware that IT Factory had entered into a number of leasing agreements, but they did not show the debt connected to those leasing agreements in IT Factory’s 2005, 2006 and 2007 annual accounts.”

According to Østergaard, lessors are not just looking at litigation against KPMG, but are also considering taking action against other lessors.

“There is a case against KPMG, but I can’t rule out that, among the creditors, more cases will arise – a lot of the creditors are telling the same story, but some of them have
been broking these lease agreements between themselves too,” he said.

Indeed, Østergaard added that some leasing companies were very proactive in landing leasing contracts with IT Factory, but would broker the agreement out to other lessors to receive a commission.

“This is not part of the official case against IT Factory or the case against KPMG, but, if you ask me, when a leasing company brokers a contract, they can be held responsible if the subject to the leasing contract does not exist,” he said.

“People are talking about it at the moment and no-one is ruling out anything.”

According to Bagger’s testimonial during his court case last month, he never had any problems borrowing money from lessors and banks for his fraudulent dealings.

“I never contacted the banks myself,” he told the court. “They contacted me to hear whether the company wanted to borrow any money.”

Asked by his defence attorney whether the banks were eager, Bagger said they were – he said that the banks conned by the leasing scheme were “throwing” money at him.

“That is putting it mildly,” Bagger insisted.

“The banks and leasing companies were contacting me. Already in 2004 and 2005, many wanted IT Factory as a client. They said there must have been something we could use loans and financing for.”

Bagger also explained why the ‘leasing carousel’ began.

“Asger Jensby had a great interest in building up his empire and he had a need for money all the time. That is why there was constant pressure from the outside world,” he said.

Swedish businessman Mikael Ljungman was named as Bagger’s partner in the scam. According to Bagger, after meeting in Stockholm in 2007, Ljungman helped Bagger run the ‘leasing carousel’.

He told the court that he received almost €2 million in cash from Ljungman between September 2007 and July 2008.

“This was a clear scam and we were both aware of it,” Bagger said, speaking of Ljungman.

Ljungman was also the person who gave Bagger his credit card and lent him his Audi when Bagger fled from Dubai to the United States.

According to Frederiksen, IT Factory’s liquidator, Ljungman is tied to six out of the 12 foreign companies that Bagger used for the scam.

“To the best of our knowledge, these are tied to Mikael Ljungman,” Frederiksen said. “It is our belief, and also based on what Stein Bagger stated during the criminal case, that these companies were just front companies.”

Full confession

On 12 June this year, Bagger, who had provided a full confession and had helped the police in their investigations, received his seven-year prison sentence from the
Danish National Court in Lyngby, just outside of Copenhagen.

The prosecutor, Per Justesen, had asked that Bagger receive a sentence of between eight and 12 years. Indeed, Justesen argued that Bagger’s fraud should be judged under a special paragraph in criminal law that enables magistrates to add 50 percent to a sentence.

“Seven years is one of the harshest verdicts ever given in this kind of case,” Lars Bo Langsted, professor of law and head of department at Aalborg University, told Leasing
Life
.

“The verdict is quite sensible. Taking into consideration that Bagger had helped the police, seven years is a proper sentence.”

Mikael Ljungman, charged with being Bagger’s associate, was arrested in Sweden at the end of April, but continues to deny all charges.

Although every effort was made to contact the lessors affected by the IT Factory fraud, none chose to comment.

However, Jesper Koefoed, a senior partner at KPMG in Denmark, said: “We believe that we, through fictitious evidence and erroneous information, also have been deceived in this case.

“Furthermore, there are at least seven fictitious documents involving the deceitful use of KPMG’s name vis-à-vis the leasing companies – also documents carrying the
forged signatures of KPMG employees.

“With the trustee’s decision, we see no other solution than bringing the case before the courts. We have considered whether we should have acted differently, but do not
think there is evidence to suggest that we should have detected the fraud in this case or that there are significant deficiencies in our work.

“No matter how much we would have enjoyed detecting the criminal acts and regardless of the fact that fraud of this kind is unpleasant for all parties concerned, it is our
view that the fraud was planned and conducted in a manner which cannot place any liability on the auditors.

“This is especially the case when fictitious documents, supplementary agreements and confirmations are part of the fraud, which is supported by the fact that the other executives and employees apparently did not suspect any misconduct in the company.”

IT Factory: leading players

Name: Allan Vestergaard
Role:
Long-time friend and business partner of Stein Bagger; former Nordea banker; owned half of Agios United SA (which owned half of IT Factory); was brutally attacked with a sledgehammer in November 2008.

Name: Anette Uttenthal
Role: Stein Bagger’s wife; claims she was not aware of the fraud; was in Dubai with Bagger when he fled to the United States.

Name: Asger Jensby
Role: Chairman of the board at IT Factory; board member of JMI Invest (which owned half of IT Factory); discovered Stein Bagger’s secret office; he has not been charged.

Name: Boris Frederiksen
Role: State-appointed liquidator for IT Factory; represents all of IT Factory’s creditors against KPMG.

Name: Erik Ove
Role:Director of public relations at IT Factory; responsible for telling the world that IT Factory was a fraud and was bankrupt.

Name: Mikael Ljungman
Role: Swedish businessman and associate of Stein Bagger; linked to six out of the 12 foreign companies that dealt in IT Factory’s ‘leasing carousel’; charged with being Bagger’s associate and aiding the fraud.

Name: Stein Bagger
Role:
CEO of IT Factory; mastermind behind the ‘leasing carousel’ fraud, sentenced to seven years in prison.

Source: Leasing Life

IT Factory: claimants

Amount (DKKm)

Danske Bank

350

IBM

147

SEB

68

HP Bank International (Hewlett Packard
FS)

32

Sydbank

25

Nordea Finans

23

Jyske Bank Group

amount unknown

Krone Kapital

amount unknown

BAL Global Finance (Bank of America
Leasing)

amount unknown

Siemens Financial Services

amount unknown

De Lage Landen

amount unknown

Source: Leasing Life

The ‘leasing carousel’: How it works

A foreign company, set up by Bagger and associates, sells ‘fictional’ equipment to IT Factory for DKK51 million ($6.9 million) and invoices are fabricated

• IT Factory (as a lessee) finances the equipment with a lessor over a fixed period

• The leasing company, paying for the equipment that IT Factory has ordered, wires the funds (DKK51 million) to Bagger’s foreign partner

• The foreign partner then buys DKK20 million of (fictional) software licences from IT Factory, thus inflating IT Factory’s sales

• Bagger’s ‘leasing carousel’ is akin to a Ponzi scheme because the model enables it to keep going round and round, until the fraud is discovered

• In this example, the foreign partner has gained DKK31 million (DKK51 million for the equipment less DKK20 million it paid to IT Factory for fake software); IT Factory has
gained DKK20 million (that the foreign company has paid to IT Factory for fake software); and the leasing company has a contract to receive DKK51 million. Bagger would honour the lease contract so as not to raise suspicions, while boosting the company’s sales.

Source: Leasing Life

IT Factory timeline: November 2008

Asger Jensby and another board member ask if they can speak to IT Factory managers, but Stein Bagger tells them that this is impossible because several
of them are travelling on business.

• Bagger’s secretary orders a room in Schæffergaarden, opposite the IT Factory offices, where Bagger sets up a secret office, used between 13 November and 19 December 2008.

Monday, 24 November 2008

• Allan Vestergaard is brutally attacked with a sledgehammer outside his home in Farum, outside of Copenhagen. The motive is unclear, although commentators assume
Vestergaard was getting close to discovering the truth behind IT Factory.

Bagger tells Erik Ove that one of his friends has been hurt and that he will visit him at Hillerød Hospital in Copenhagen.

Tuesday, 25 November 2008

• The domain name EOkommunikation.com is registered with a US internet company and is used to send out emails to try to buy out Jensby and JMI Invest, who part-own IT Factory.

Wednesday, 26 November 2008

Bagger travels to Dubai with his wife, Anette Uttenthal, and some friends, on a holiday.

Thursday, 27 November 2008

Ernst & Young awards IT Factory the ‘Danish Growth Champion’ prize, and ‘Entrepreneur of the Year’ award to Bagger.

• In Dubai, Bagger leaves his seat during dinner and does not return.

Bagger withdraws DKK23,000 (€3,000) twice, rents a car and drives through the desert to Abu Dhabi.

Vestergaard speaks to Jensby, telling him that he owns half of Agios United SA, Bagger’s holding company owns the other half of IT Factory, and that he intends to acquire Jensby’s shares in IT Factory the next day.

Friday, 28 November 2008

Bagger flies out of Abu Dhabi and arrives in New York the same day, where he borrows Mikael Ljungman’s credit card and Audi, to drive across the US.

Jensby and an associate from JMI Invest visit IT Factory’s headquarters in Gentofte, Copenhagen, and begin an extensive audit.

• Following the attack on Vestergaard, Danish police obtain a warrant to tap Bagger’s phone.

Saturday, 29 November 2008

Uttenthal officially reports that Bagger is missing.

Jensby and his associate continue their audit until late at night, when they find a key-card in Bagger’s office.

Sunday, 30 November 2008

• The key-card leads Jensby to Bagger’s secret Schæffergaarden office and he discovers documents revealing a fraud worth around DKK0.5 billion. During the
search, four passports in Bagger’s name are found.

Monday, 1 December 2008

Jensby reports the situation to the police.

• At a press conference, Jensby and Erik Ove publicly declare that IT Factory is bankrupt and that the “vast majority” of its business was invented.

Wednesday, 3 December 2008

• Police remove computer equipment from Vestergaard’s home.

Thursday, 4 December 2008

Vestergaard publicly distances himself from Bagger, saying that he knows nothing about the fraud.

Bagger is charged with fabricating false documents and a fraud in excess of DKK500 million .

• In a closed-doors court hearing, Bagger is jailed in absentia.

• Police search Bagger’s and Vestergaard’s homes.

Friday, 5 December 2008

• Interpol officially declares that Bagger is “wanted for fraud”.

Bagger arrives in Los Angeles, where he checks into the Hollywood Best Western hotel.

Saturday, 6 December 2008

Bagger turns himself in to the Los Angeles Police Department and is arrested.

Wednesday, 10 December 2008

Boris Frederiksen issues a statement in which he estimates the total value of remaining assets at IT Factory to be worth DKK123 million, but that the accumulated fraud is estimated around DKK1.2 billion.

Frederiksen concludes that the company has been living off fictitious transactions, although the amount from the fraud by which Bagger has personally benefited is still unknown.

Friday, 12 December 2008

• All 45 employees of the scandal-hit and bankrupt IT Factory are made redundant.

Tuesday, 16 December 2008

Bagger is extradited to Denmark and is taken straight to court from the airport, where he admits to his part of the fraud.

Thursday, 18 December 2008

• The police confiscate Bagger’s and Uttenthal’s exclusive Copenhagen apartment, as well as their other assets.

Tuesday, 23 December 2008

Bagger is attacked in jail and is admitted to hospital, where he receives stitches. He refuses to say who attacked him.

Tuesday, 6 January 2009

Frederiksen announces that 12 leasing companies have made claims exceeding DKK1 billion against IT Factory.

Tuesday, 20 January 2009

Ljungman is charged with involvement in the IT Factory fraud and is given 14 days to turn himself in.

Tuesday, 3 March 2009

• Online auctioneer Lauritz.com sells all of IT Factory’s furniture and art, raising DKK1.6 million.

Friday, 27 March 2009

• At a court hearing, Bagger admits to committing fraud worth DKK831 million and is charged with the attack on Vestergaard.

Tuesday, 31 March 2009

Ljungman is imprisoned in absentia, charged with helping Bagger fabricate fraudulent documents that led to a DKK266 million scam.

Wednesday, 22 April 2009

• Interpol declares Ljungman as wanted.

Monday, 27 April 2009

Ljungman is arrested in Norrköping, Sweden.

Wednesday, 10 June 2009

Bagger’s trial begins at Lyngby Court, in Copenhagen, where it is expected he will receive a custodial sentence of between eight and 12 years.

Friday, 12 June 2009

Bagger is sentenced to seven years in jail.

Source: Leasing Life